Introducing New Toys to Your Pet – The Right (and Wrong) Way to Do It

You finally got your pet that amazing new toy you were sure they’d love. You excitedly present it to them… and they sniff it, look at you like you just insulted their ancestors, and walk away. Sound familiar? Don’t worry—you’re not alone. Introducing new toys to your pet is an art, and like all great artists, you need the right technique.

Step 1: Know Your Audience (aka Your Pet’s Personality)

Before you hand over the new toy, take a second to think: What kind of pet am I dealing with?

• The Enthusiast: They’ll play with anything, including empty boxes, your shoes, and air. No worries here—just toss the toy and watch the chaos unfold.
• The Skeptic: They eye everything new with deep suspicion. You’ll need to build some trust before they even think about touching it.
• The Spoiled One: If it’s not top-tier, five-star, premium-grade fun, they’re not interested. Challenge accepted.

Step 2: The Big Reveal (Or, How to Make It Exciting)

Simply plopping the toy in front of your pet and walking away? Rookie mistake. Instead, try this:

• Make It Seem Like a Big Deal – Hype it up! Get excited, make silly noises, and show them that this new thing is the best thing ever.
• Play With It First – Yep, you might look ridiculous rolling a ball or squeaking a toy in your hands, but trust me, curiosity will get the best of them.
• Use Treats – Everything is better when snacks are involved. Reward them when they interact with the toy.

Step 3: Avoiding Toy-Related Drama

There are a few rookie mistakes that can turn your exciting new purchase into an ignored dust collector: ❌ Forcing It on Them – Let them explore it at their own pace. ❌ Overloading Them – Giving too many new toys at once can be overwhelming. Introduce one at a time. ❌ Ignoring Size and Material – Make sure the toy is safe and appropriate for your pet’s size and chewing habits.

Step 4: Keep the Fun Going

Pets, like toddlers, can get bored quickly. Keep things fresh by rotating toys, engaging in interactive play, and mixing things up. That way, every toy feels new again!

Time to Treat Your Pet!

Now that you know the secrets to introducing new toys the right way, it’s time to find the perfect ones! Check out our hand-picked selection of fun, durable, and pet-approved toys—because a happy pet means a happy you. 🐾